Digital Tools for Revisiting Presentations

In my previous post, I explained what I wanted to advise students who want to improve how they take and study lecture notes. I explained the techniques in the context of academic, large-lecture settings, but many would be relevant to those taking, storing, and using notes for self-directed learning. In that post, I divided the time between exposure to the application of information into three stages, which I labeled revisit, revise, and review. The quality of each stage in this sequence is limited by the quality of and access to the tangible products of the previous stage. My advice for students is not to focus on studying the night before the exam (i.e., review), but to recognize all stages in this sequence.

Information explicitly recorded in notes is significantly more likely to be retrieved and answered correctly on exams than information missed during lecture capture. Before you dismiss this observation as one of those obvious things researchers spend their time demonstrating, remember what I said about the stages of taking and studying notes being a feed-forward system. It is worth considering what we can do to avoid being limited from the start (e.g., Courtney and colleagues).

There are remedies students can apply. For example, students can compare what they have collected with what colleagues have collected, filling in gaps and correcting misunderstandings. An option I studied when I was involved in active research was described as “expert notes” – notes provided by the lecturer or perhaps a graduate student assistant required to attend large lecture classes. Both approaches have proven to be helpful (Kiewra, 1985). One issue I studied was whether offering a complete set of notes reduced lecture attendance (Grabe and Colleague).

I should make this point clear. None of the ways I propose to improve the use of notes are intended to reduce student note-taking. The generative effect of trying to generate a quality set of notes is a benefit no matter the quality of what you produce. 

Do It Yourself

There are several ways you can use a digital device to address the predictable difficulty we all have in producing complete and accurate notes. 

Here are some specific suggestions for tools and techniques related to the first or revisit stage. 

Several apps allow you to synchronize the notes you take with recorded audio of the presentation. This means that if you tap a specific location in your notes, the app will replay the exact audio you were hearing when you took that note. So, if something doesn’t make sense, you can listen to that part of the presentation again. If you don’t understand and know you missed something, enter something like ??? in your notes and you can return when you have more time to more carefully process that information. Goodnotes and Notability are popular apps with this capability. Constant use requires a subscription plan. I have used SoundNote because it requires only an inexpensive, one-time purchase. 

Here is a problem I can’t find a solution for and I wonder what others are doing as they must encounter the same problem. I use this app when I am working on my desktop machine and want to take notes from a podcast or similar presentation. When I try to use it on my laptop, which I assume most students have, the clicking sound I make while taking notes gets recorded along with the presentation audio, and I can’t really understand the resulting recording. 

Just Transcribe The Audio

Here is an alternative that seems reasonable. Just use an app on your phone in a classroom setting that records audio and then generates a transcription. There seem to be hundreds of ways to do this, usually recommended for those who find a need to record “meeting notes.” These apps work the same in a classroom as long as the audio is loud enough to be picked up.

Take your own notes on a separate device. Use your phone only for the audio recording and transcription. This combination provides the benefits of generative note-taking and serves as a backup to your personal notes if you miss something or get confused when you review them. There is no direct link between your notes and the transcription, but it is easy to relate the two representations of the presentation and see where they match in each sequence. Skimming this section of the transcription works well.

My preference for going this way, because I use all Apple technology, is to use a feature of Apple Notes that many have likely ignored. After I use my phone to take and store the recording and transcription, I prefer opening the same note, automatically available on my iPad, to read and review the transcription. 

The following sequence of screen captures from my phone walks you through the steps to capture audio and generate a transcription. First, open a new note and select the “paper clip” icon, which opens a menu with the “record audio” option. 

Once you are recording, or after you have finished, there is an icon in the bottom left-hand corner that will display the transcription. 

Summary

Digital tools allow a note taker to revisit a presentation and check for missing information and misunderstandings. Two approaches are described in this post.

Resources

Courtney, M., Costley, J., Baldwin, M., Lee, K., & Fanguy, M. (2022). Individual versus collaborative note-taking: Results of a quasi-experimental study on student note completeness, test performance, and academic writing. The Internet and Higher Education, 55, 100873.

Grabe, M., & Christopherson, K. (2008). Optional student use of online lecture resources: resource preferences, performance and lecture attendance. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 24(1), 1-10.

Kiewra, K. A. (1985). Providing the instructor’s notes: An effective addition to student notetaking. Educational Psychologist, 20(1), 33-39.

Kiewra, K. A. (1987). Notetaking and review: the research and its implications. Instructional Science, 16(3), 233–249

Loading

Studying Notes: Revisit, Revise, Review 

Making studying more productive is my research thing. I assume motivation and then consider how best to go about learning in the aftermath of reading or listening. I have a bias toward the use of technology, which seems to run counter to those who have tuned in to the recent “take notes on paper and not using a computer crowd.” I could and have written extensively about my resistance to this message. Briefly, my logic goes like this. Whether you buy the handwritten-notes-are-better perspective or not, the difference in how important note-taking is accomplished is small compared to the impact of what most people would call studying. Digital notes are better suited to stronger study strategies. This advantage matters especially for those of us beyond our classroom experiences who are self-directed, lifelong learners, using notes to advance our careers or personal knowledge interests. 

By “studying,” I mean a Revisit – Revise – Review framework that may help you reflect on your own study habits and identify activities that might be promoted for students. The framework is intended to explain what could happen post-exposure (reading or listening) and before the application of what has been learned (testing, project application). 

One quick related comment before I continue. All the recommendations I make aside, perhaps a bigger issue is whether learners are aware of and taught study strategies. This topic deserves an extended analysis. Folks like me, steeped in cognitive psychology and what learning involves, can typically propose principles and practices that make sense and have probably been tested in carefully controlled research studies. The transition to what I guess we’d call the diffusion of such ideas somehow seems to break down. We teach many “how to” skills in formal education, but who is responsible for teaching, modeling, and evaluating “how to learn skills”? Is it, we assume such skills are common sense? Is it, we assume it is someone else who should be responsible? We seem alarmed by how much content is easily available to us, but mostly we throw up our hands rather than ask even the most basic questions about what we offer as strategies learners can use to process this information. 


Revisit

What we hear or read lingers in our minds for a bit. This isn’t what we cognitive psychologists call short-term memory, although I guess your STM would be included, but I’m thinking more of the Ebbinghaus forgetting curve. What we retain without purposeful activity drops quickly, and the earlier we can pay attention to what exists the better off we are long term. Using information as soon as possible changes the long-term consequences of the forgetting curve. So a time frame like the rest of the day following a lecture would allow for what I call the revisit stage. Perhaps unusual to some, researchers have shown the benefits of inserting pauses within lectures to encourage revisiting information just presented (Luo and colleagues, 2016). The supposed advantage of handwritten notes assumes immediate personalization through summarization, which also fits this category because it assumes summarizing key points immediately after reception. There is no logical reason taking notes on a keyboard does not involve summarization because the greater speed of capturing ideas should allow more time for thinking, but I guess this is not how most learners use the time – they tend to just record more. 

More to my focus on revisiting, aking a look at your notes after class, or even after the day’s classes, still gives you access to information not included in the existing notes.  This is a chance to modify and extend the notes you took by adding what you remember but what doesn’t currently appear on the page or screen. Skimming your notes does not require much time; the practice involves retrieval practice if what is there relates to your memory of class, and may allow you to add a few details and recognize confusions. I can’t argue that digital offers a great opportunity while skimming, but again, the advantage I see requires that you start with digital. 

Revise

Key productive activities in the period of time between the exposure to information and the application of that information are typically categorized as either retrieval practice or generative. Retrieval practice tactics such as flashcards or practice tests primarily increase the likelihood that information already in memory remains available, or increases the probability that it becomes available. These activities are important, but not the focus here. Generative activities grow the present level of understanding and application value both of what is stored externally (the notes) and in memory. Such activities can include an indirect form of retrieval practice because working with what is externally stored as notes is related to existing information stored in memory, which obviously involves retrieval. For example, generating examples that fit general principles or concepts presented in class uses existing knowledge to extend what might already be stored in notes. Such generative activities may occur purely as a mental activity or be externalized by adding such ideas to the notes that already exist.

The basic insight with generative activities is to treat in-class notes as raw material rather than a finished product. Beyond revisiting what you recorded, active note modification, gap filling, and structural reorganization are ways to work with or think about your notes. One revision strategy is tagging, linking, and separating summaries into independent notes, popularized by those interested in digital personal knowledge management systems, and is more easily accomplished within a digital environment (e.g., Obsidian). Paper-based strategies such as the Cornell note-taking method are another. With Cornell notes (imagine a page divided vertically into a wide right-hand column and a narrow left-hand column with a horizontal space at the bottom), the physical structure of the page provides a template for revision. Comments related to the notes, questions, additions, etc. are to be entered in the left-hand column during study sessions. Use the area at the bottom of the page for a summary. 

Study groups have always been a strong, concrete suggestion for learners who want to improve their performance. Cross-checking notes with colleagues is successful because what ends up in your notes is a strong predictor of what you can recall. If you only cross-check for errors and completeness, that is significant, but interacting with peers also encourages you to explore how others understand challenging concepts and can involve retrieval practice if you are expected to answer questions posed by others in the group. Fanguy and colleagues (2021) found that a variable they labeled turn-taking significantly predicted performance. Members of those groups involved in more interactions were the most successful.

While I always asked students who commented that they had no idea how they might improve their understanding whether they ever interacted with another student from the class to discuss their lecture and reading content, I tend to think of study groups as more common among higher-level and more demanding content (much of my thinking about note-taking from lectures was centered on the many times I taught Introduction to Psychology to very large groups of students). 

Proposal for a study group meeting. Perhaps formulaic, but the description of activities seems useful. 

1. Silent read-through (5 min). Each person reads all sets without talking. No copying yet.

2. Gap hunt, one topic at a time (20 min). Go section by section and ask specific questions. “We all have the definition; did anyone get the example she gave?” “I have ‘three factors’ but only two names — what was the third?” This is the difference between simple sharing (adds volume) and collaborative retrieval (adds learning) 

3. Reconstruct aloud (10 min). One person explains a segment from memory while others check against their notes and correct. This is where turn-taking earns its correlation with achievement Fanguyetal2023notes.

4. Resolve disputes from the source. If two notes conflict, go back to the recording, slides or textbook rather than majority vote. Cross-checking is the accuracy benefit.

5. Individual close (10 min). Everyone writes their own one-paragraph summary or five-question self-quiz from the merged notes, closed-book. This protects the encoding you would otherwise lose, and gives you a retrieval-practice event rather than a rereading event.

One caveat. The research on collaborative note-taking reminds me of many similar issues with AI. If they have access to the notes taken by peers some may come to rely on such notes and at an extreme even skip classes. When explored in the field, as compared to more controlled laboratory studies in which students likely take a more idealistic approach, experiencing the benefits, but the results from access to the notes of peers or experts in actual classes are more mixed. 

Review

If you followed the revision advice, you have already learned not to rely on cramming. In the last day or two before an important exam, keep using retrieval practice activities, not just to identify gaps in understanding, but also because focusing on producing information from memory reduces test-taking anxiety. Old tests are useful because they provide opportunities for retrieval practice and offer insights into what your instructor is likely to ask. Long-term retrieval practice helps even when you don’t produce the correct answer because the process activates related information. However, at this stage, it is important to identify correct answers, as you don’t want to leave incorrect answers as the last thing you remember.

You likely have some insights into areas that you find particularly difficult and allocate the time you study accordingly. Use these metacognitive insights to apply time productively.

Summary

 The time between when you take notes and the day or two before the next exams offers the opportunity to develop a better understanding and increase long term retention. By intentionally moving through the stages of revisiting your recollection of a lecture, revising raw notes to expand and integrate what you recorded, and reviewing the products of previous work shortly before an exam, learners transform raw records into enduring, lifelong knowledge. Maybe, all things considered, the biggest insight here is that there are three stages and moving directly from taking notes to review is the limited approach too many take. 

Sources:

Butterfield, B., Metcalfe, J. The correction of errors committed with high confidence. Metacognition and Learning 1, 69–84 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11409-006-6894-z

Cohen, D., Kim, E., Tan, J., & Winkelmes, M. A. (2013). A note-restructuring intervention increases students’ exam scores. College Teaching, 61(3), 95-99.

Courtney, M., Costley, J., Baldwin, M., Lee, K., & Fanguy, M. (2022). Individual versus collaborative note-taking: Results of a quasi-experimental study on student note completeness, test performance, and academic writing. The Internet and Higher Education, 55, 100873.

Fanguy, M., Baldwin, M., Shmeleva, E., Lee, K., & Costley, J. (2021). How collaboration influences the effect of note-taking on writing performance and recall of contents. Interactive Learning Environments, 1-15.

Luo, L., Kiewra, K. A., & Samuelson, L. (2016). Effects of lecture pauses on student note-taking and learning. Journal of Educational Psychology, 108(3), 342-353. doi: 10.1037/edu0000139

Loading

Microlearning, Segmented Lectures, and Producing More Useful Notes

A colleague of mine runs a book club in which I participate and as we often do, we deviated from discussing the “book of the month” to discuss other matters. A recent discussion focused on his efforts to redo his online history courses using microlectures (an example). Ideas seem to “cross-fertilize” for me, and the idea of microlectures (microlearning) surfaced thoughts from recent reading I have been doing on how lectures tend to challenge quality note-taking, and how segmented lectures could improve the related studying that follows. By segmented lectures, I mean a lecture in which the presenter pauses to allow time for a student task. My personal exposure to segmented lectures came from a classroom redesign that faculty colleagues who received instructional development money created, in which students sat around tables to listen to lectures. This arrangement was intended to let the instructor pause and require students at each table to engage in some form of “active learning” task. The demos I witnessed did not involve note-taking, but as I will describe at a later point, comparing notes during these pauses could have been an option. My own classes were too large (180+) so even this special “lecture” setting would not have been adequate. 

Microlectures, a subcategory of microlearning, tend to use short, focused videos in which an instructor explains a single key concept or specific skill. These tend to be videos rather than live presentations and are a common nonclassroom “just-in-time” learning approach. Most of us have experienced this approach without ever labeling it. When I spent a lot of time learning specific programming techniques (e.g., PHP), I purchased access to a service (Lynda) that offered video courses made up of short segments (3-10 minutes) covering specific skills. I see Lynda has morphed into something new, perhaps because it is easy to find similar videos at no cost from YouTube. Microlectures are common in what some would describe as “training” environments, but not in academic settings. However, It appears that “short presentation” videos made an appearance during the COVID years to hold the attention of those trying to learn under those circumstances, and they may be an example of what became known as a “flipped classroom” (short videos to watch before a class meeting). Now that our instructional situations have returned to more traditional approaches, the approach my history colleague is using seems relatively rare.  

Segmented Lectures and Taking Notes

I created the phrase “segmented lectures” to describe a strategy I encountered while reading research studies that sought ways to improve lecture notes and the subsequent study experience based on those notes. The strategy required the instructor to pause during a traditional lecture to focus on improving the notes taken during the previous presentation segment. Hopefully, you can see how I connected this to the microlectures body of work. My personal interest as a digital note taker was piqued by research that claimed handwritten notes contributed to better understanding because handwriting is relatively slower than keyboarding, and to keep up, students have to select the most important content and summarize it instead of recording ideas verbatim. Through what I see as twisted logic, a less efficient process was somehow claimed to produce a more effective outcome. 

The intersection of microlectures and note-taking becomes especially compelling when you examine what cognitive research reveals about how students actually capture and retain lecture material. Most educators and students think of note-taking as a two-stage activity: recording during class and reviewing before an exam. Researchers (e.g., Luo and colleagues) argue that this view overlooks the critical middle stage: note revision.

The practical problem revision addresses is important. When students take notes in a single pass during continuous speech, they typically capture only about a third of the important information presented. While main ideas are noted reasonably well, secondary details and deeper conceptual relationships drop off precipitously, leaving massive gaps. Because missing a concept from lecture notes reduces the likelihood of recalling it on an exam, note completeness directly dictates student achievement.

This is precisely where the design of segmented lectures and microlectures relates to these empirical findings. Researchers proposed that lectures might pause periodically to let students review the notes just taken and make adjustments. Some studies outlined specific ways to make these delays productive. For example, Flannigan and colleagues paired students to enrich their idea collection. When students compare notes with a partner, they prompt each other to recall omitted details and examples through collaborative retrieval. While sharing notes alone doesn’t automatically lift test scores, the interactive dialogue helps students identify blind spots in their individual records. It was this strategy that reminded me of the “active learning” concept I explained earlier. 

Studies comparing different revision routines found that pausing periodically throughout a lesson to let students revise their notes yielded significantly better results than waiting until the entire lecture finished. Short, distributed revision breaks, say two to three minutes, allow students to use the fragments they just jotted down as immediate retrieval cues to fill in missing logic and flesh out partial thoughts before cognitive decay sets in.

Contrary to my expectations, Flanigan and collaborators tested the full sequence of recording, revising, and reviewing and found that students taking longhand notes benefited more from revision intervals than those typing on laptops. Longhand note-takers added roughly three times as many complete ideas during pause breaks and performed half a letter grade higher on subsequent assessments. I have no explanation for this difference. 

Bringing these threads back to microlearning and segmented design, short, tightly focused instructional segments bounded by deliberate pauses offer a natural answer to the note-taking dilemma. Instead of treating lecture videos or classroom talks as uninterrupted streams of delivery, brief pauses transform passive viewing into active processing. Whether students use those two minutes to flesh out shorthand points, draw connections, or cross-check key takeaways, carving out dedicated time for revision converts a fleeting lecture into a durable, complete study record. (see Zheng). 

Summary:

A lengthy lecture overwhelms most learners’ ability to take useful study notes. Both pausing during a lecture (segmented lectures) or using short, focused video lectures (microlectures) allow learners the time to create notes more effective for study.

Sources:

Flanigan, A. E., Kiewra, K. A., Lu, J., & Dzhuraev, D. (2023). Computer versus longhand note taking: Influence of revision. Instructional Science, 51(2), 251-284

Luo, L., Kiewra, K. A., & Samuelson, L. (2016). Revising lecture notes: how revision, pauses, and partners affect note-taking and achievement. Instructional Science, 44(1), 45-67.

Zheng, H. (2022). Short and sweet: The educational benefits of microlectures and active learning. EDUCAUSE Review. https://er.educause.edu/articles/2022/2/short-and-sweet-the-educational-benefits-of-microlectures-and-active-learning

Loading

The misinterpretation of desirable difficulty when it comes to PKM

I became interested in what I now describe as the great keyboarding versus handwritten note-taking controversy after I had retired from my career as an educational psychologist and I could no longer conduct research. I had studied student note-taking and related topics intended to improve student performance so I had experiences that seemed relevant. As retired people do, I looked for things to do that interested me and came across a book study group reading about personal knowledge management (PKM). These folks were old school so I learned about Niklas Luhmann’s Zettelkasten slip-based (think note card) system for storing, organizing, and applying notes over an extended period of time. The topic of whether implementations among lifelong learners such as the members of this group should use handwritten notes stored or modernized versions of the Zettelkasten stored digitally (think Obsidian) came up frequently again raised the handwriting vs. keyboarding controversy. 

Unless they follow the research carefully, it is my impression that high school teachers and college profs are getting the message that learners are better off if they require students to take notes by hand. The issue is that learners’ attention can wander when they are online and have a device, but the most persuasive argument seems to be that learners, no matter how distractible, achieve greater understanding when taking notes by hand. I have tried to summarize the limitations of the handwriting is better argument in previous posts. 

The desirability difficulty hypothesis

Why would this be the case? The most common explanation is based in the observation that students can record more information when using a keyboard because a keyboard tends to be faster than handwriting. On the surface, this difference might seem to advantage students who take notes on a tablet or laptop, as students who enter information faster would seem better able to keep up with a lecturer. 

The desirable difficulty hypothesis is used to reach a different conclusion (Bork and Bork, 2011. Desirable difficulty is a learning condition that makes practice feel more effortful and often makes performance look worse in the moment, but improves long-term retention and transfer. It can apply in many areas (e.g., do you highlight or take notes when you read), but here is based on the proposal that the slower rate of handwritten notes in the context of the demanding rate of information presentation in a lecture forces students to make decisions about what they will get down on paper. They argue that students focus on the most important information and rework the auditory input in their own words. When writing about another of my personal interests, I would describe this as a generative rather than a passive process (verbatim notes). It always struck me that those who take notes using keyboards actually have more time to think rather than less and this assumes they ignore this advantage by being lazy. 

If you have read Thinking fast and slow (Kahneman) you have encountered the researcher’s distinction between System 1 and System 2 thinking. Fast thinking is by definition, fast and effortless and slow thinking is deliberate and effortful. Kahneman probably wouldn’t conclude that we are by nature lazy thinkers, but he does claim that the default is to cognitive behavior that is fast to conserve mental energy. We have to make a deliberate effort to override this tendency. In this situation, unless learners purposefully summarize and personalize as they take notes, the default will be to record what you can. Handwriters are forced into thinking because of the greater stress they are under. They have no choice. Perhaps keyboarders could function differently, but don’t know or don’t care.

There are options to reduce the stress (the audio recording option) and create more effective notes when working with a computer or tablet. 

As I have thought more about this I now wonder why the PKM folks use the same handwriting during lecture explanation to do the work they do. They are typically reading and, if listening to podcasts or YouTube, but have access to the pause button. Perhaps more to my issue with the desirable difficulty explanation for greater generative processing and the recommendations for the PKM folks to take their notes by hand is the lack of reasoning as to why desirable difficulty would even apply when you read. It might apply to something like highlighting versus taking notes, but given the control available to the reader, how would it relate to taking notes? If working memory was being overloaded by some combination of reading and taking notes, how would that work? You can’t do both at the same time.  I have been trying to find research studies on keyboarding versus handwriting as applied to text content, but there seems to be very, very little. 

The one study I could find (Shoen) was a graduate program thesis comparing handwritten and keyboarded notes from an “equivalent” audio and text source. The researcher made the same comment I just made about the lack of studies comparing typewritten (his term) and handwritten notes from text. The researcher found a main effect showing the advantage of “typed” notes and even an interaction showing that handwritten notes from audio produced lower retention than the other groups. This study focused on the encoding effect rather than a storage benefit, meaning the posttest was given soon after an interference task rather than after an effort to let participants consider the benefits of studying the notes. 

One related point. I am differentiating annotation of written content from taking notes. My rationale is that writing a few words in the margins which can occur when reading a book is quantitatively and qualitatively different from adding a note to text content when using a digital reading platform such as a Kindle. There are not restrictions because of space and a very different opportunity to review (search, rework. etc) notes taken digitally. 

Summary

This post focuses mainly on the desirable difficulty argument as an explanation for the superiority of handwritten notes. More specifically, I try to argue that those interested in taking notes from text or video, as is the case with most of the note-taking by PKM enthusiasts has little support from those claiming that there is research showing the benefits of handwritten notes. 

Sources

Bjork, E. L., & Bjork, R. A. (2011). Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning. Psychology and the real world: Essays illustrating fundamental contributions to society, 2(59-68), 56-64.

Kahneman, D., & Egan, P. (2011). Thinking, fast and slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Schoen, Ian, “Effects of Method and Context of Note-taking on Memory: Handwriting versus Typing in Lecture and Textbook-Reading Contexts” (2012). Pitzer Senior Theses. Paper 20. http://scholarship.claremont.edu/pitzer_theses/20

Loading

Digital Devices and Effective Studying and Long-Term Note Use

Lately, I seem to encounter a great deal of advice warning against reading and note-taking on a device. Paper and a pencil are argued to be better. In a recent post, I argued that I found these complaints ill-advised. This is a second attempt to present the same argument and a different way to justify my position.

Most simply put, I don’t think the researchers and I are talking about the same thing, even though it seems the anti-tech types would make the case that we are. The research frequently cited reading and taking notes tend to focus on more focused and short-term processes than what I have in mind. My focus, and I think the actual focus of most learners, is more on what I might describe as studying or the use of notes as imagined by the PKM/Second Brain aficionados. When I read a fiction book for pleasure, I might have a better understanding of that book if I read the content on paper. This is very different from how I would best get from reading a textbook to doing well on an exam a couple of months from now. A similar comparison might be made with taking notes during a lecture. I would seldom be taking notes for an exam the same day, but more likely for one week away. 

Process Models

I write a lot about process models relevant to understanding and developing both learning skills and the knowledge that results from applying those skills. The process model of writing (Flower & Hayes) makes a good example. These researchers proposed that a process model of writing was useful to researchers because the model identified subskills that could be studied to see how these contributing skills might explain the performance of more and less effective writers and to educators trying to understand what contributing behaviors might be isolated for practice and development. 

I suggest that the same type of process model would be helpful for developing study skills and for taking a different look at the possible advantages of using digital devices for reading and note-taking. The argument in this second case is that research comparing tech vs. traditional approaches has overlooked important processes in studying and note-taking applications.

Processes in tasks involving the collection and eventual application of information

There have been efforts to identify the processes involved in translating a presentation (e.g., a lecture or book chapter) into intended applications. Several researchers (e.g., Cojean & Grand, 2024; Flanigan et al., 2023; Luo et al., 2016) have extended the original two-stage model (note-taking and external storage) to emphasize the importance of revision. Returning to the importance of multi-process models in understanding the potential issue of whether it matters if one takes notes on paper or using a device, the studies differ. Flanigan and colleagues engaged the unusual practice of inserting pauses during a presentation to allow for revision and found that those taking notes by hand created more revisions. In contrast, Cojean and Grand found that after class those taking notes on a device made more revisions. Systems of taking notes, for example Cornell Notes (Pauk & Owens, 2011) and recent PKM systems (Ahrens, 2022; Forte, 2022), differentiate revision as a separate process in the use of notes. 

In the spirit of the writing process model, I have created my own identification of note-taking and note-using processes listed as a sequence with the recognition that notetakers frequently revisit earlier processes after finding a limitation in what a later process makes available. The sequence of descriptors for these processes follows. 

  • Collecting
  • Considering
  • Elaborating 
  • Exporting

Collecting – creating a representation of content (presentations, videos, text material) for use in the future

Examples – creating annotations, notes, highlights

Considering  – offline processing of the information collected for personal understanding and to evaluate gaps in understanding

Examples – rewrite existing notes based on comparison of personal collection with that of peers, return to source material to fill in gaps

Elaborating – speculation based on personal understanding of original information for fit within existing knowledge and potential application

Examples – links to existing notes on similar topics, Internet searches to locate and augment existing notes with additional examples of key concepts

Exporting – use of cumulative stored content to meet personal or assigned goals

      Examples – test performance, assigned writing tasks, personal writing projects

The Processes and The Question of Handwriting vs. Digital

My contention is that when tasks involve all of the processes I have identified, digital tools offer advantages in the efficiency of collection, storage, search, and manipulation. These advantages are magnified when the task’s time frame is extended and initial goals are unclear. I have written at length on these topics and I have tried to organize some of these posts, organized by process, below. I have avoided considering how AI might be used in these processes, but such engagement would be far easier if working in a digital environment. 

Collecting

Take digital notes for best lecture performance

Note and highlight extraction for efficient review and storage (Readwise for books, Highlights for PDFs)

Considering

Note and highlight extraction for efficient review and storage (Readwise for books, Highlights for PDFs)

The Power of Collaboration: Enhancing Your Note-Taking Experience

Preserving context in digital writing

Elaborating

Smart Connections finds note connections

Highlighting in the age of digital content

Notes and the Translation Process

The Space Between Encountering Information and Application

Digital for serious reading tasks

School and Professional Note-Taking

Exporting

School and Professional Note-Taking

Resources

Ahrens, S. (2022). How to take smart notes: One simple technique to boost writing, learning and thinking. 

Cojean, S., &  Grand, M. (2024). Note-taking by university students on paper or a computer: Strategies during initial note-taking and revision. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 94, 557–570. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjep.12663

Flanigan, A. E., Kiewra, K. A., Lu, J., & Dzhuraev, D. (2023). Computer versus longhand note-taking: Influence of revision. Instructional Science, 51(2), 251-284

Forte, T. (2022). Building a second brain: A proven method to organize your digital life and unlock your creative potential. Simon and Schuster.

Luo, L., Kiewra, K. A., & Samuelson, L. (2016). Revising lecture notes: How revision, pauses, and partners affect note-taking and achievement. Instructional Science, 44(1), 45-67.

Pauk, W., & Owens, R, (2011). How to study in college. Boston, MA: Wadsworth, Cengage Learning.

Loading

What you think the research on handwritten vs keyboarded notetaking shows is flawed

If you’ve spent any time reading about study strategies, you’ve probably encountered some version of this claim: writing notes by hand is better than typing them on a laptop. There seems to be or at least there is reported to be research to back it up. I am normally a “what does the research suggest” guy, but in this case, I am skeptical and find my own experience leads me to a different conclusion.   

I try to be careful in thinking through whether any research study matches well with learner behavior in applied settings. To do this, you need to do more than read the abstract or even the discussion section from published studies. You certainly need to do more than read the analyses from “thought leaders” who have only read this content or asked AI to offer an opinion. Here is why. Researchers are free to speculate a bit in pushing an interpretation in these parts of a journal article. Readers should know this and take this into account. The section of the article, expected to be objective and descriptive, is the Methods section. Think of your role as a research consumer like this: here is exactly what he/she did and the results that these experiences produced. Now interpret them yourself given what you know about existing research and knowledge of the Methods and Results in this study. What conclusions do you reach?

Here are some issues I think are important to consider when researching keyboard versus handwritten note-taking.  I have ordered this list from most to least influential based on my perception of what matters most when considering what a given study offers for applied note-taking. Don’t take this ranking too seriously, but think about the impact the issues I identify might have.

Look for this issue in the Methods section.

Does the study focus on taking notes from a live lecture? The experience of taking notes from written material or a recorded source is different. You can pause and do not have to experience the working memory overload argued to trigger the more generative processing required to counter the slower process of handwriting? I include this item because so many adults have become interested in Personal Knowledge Management (PKM) strategies and are exposed to summaries of the research on notetaking. The PKM people seem more likely to take notes in response to what they read than students.

Does the study allow a reasonable amount of time to review notes? Does the experiment allow note review or does it focus on learning during the lecture only? What you learn during the input experience is not the entire learning opportunity.

Does the study involve a significant delay between exposure to content and before the collection of the dependent variable? Is the performance data collected as part of the same research session as the input experience?

Is intermediate processing of notes allowed or encouraged? Looking over notes immediately after taking them is a good strategy for students.

Is the digital experience limited to the original input of information? I encourage lecture focused note takers to use an app that records audio while taking notes. Such apps link notes with the audio. This allows gaps or vague notes to be remediated from the time-linked audio in a very efficient manner.  Missing something doesn’t have to be permanent and technology allows an easy way to address this issue.

An example of how I analyze a screen/paper study

I have read a large proportion of the published studies comparing keyboard and pen notetaking and have frequently written about my opinions on this matter. I decided to create this post after encountering an oft-cited study I had missed and in reading this study found some of the issues I have just mentioned. Comments related to this specific study may offer additional insights into what I think is being missed.

A 2018 study by Luo, Kiewra, Flanigan, and Peteranetz compared laptop and longhand note-taking and arrived at conclusions that many educators have taken as gospel. Laptop note takers, the study found, tend to transcribe lectures verbatim. They capture more words and paraphrase less. The researchers argue that longhand note takers, constrained by writing speed, are forced to be selective – to summarize and to impose structure. When students later reviewed their notes, the longhand group outperformed the laptop group on achievement measures. The takeaway seemed clear: put down the laptop and take your notes on paper.

But here’s the problem. The study, like many in this line of research, created conditions that almost no student would actually encounter in a real academic setting. And in doing so, the researchers may have reached conclusions that say more about experimental design than about how learning actually works.

What Happens After You Take Notes?

Think about your own experience as a student. Did you ever just take notes during a lecture and then re-read them once before a test? Maybe. But more likely, you did something with those notes afterward. You reorganized them. You filled in gaps possibly be asked to look at a friend’s notes. You rewrote messy sections. You looked up concepts you didn’t understand and added explanations. You highlighted key ideas, drew connections between topics, or created study guides.

These processes – note modification and active review – are where much of the real learning happens. And it’s precisely the step that the Luo et al. study skipped nearly entirely.

In the study, the review condition gave students just 15 minutes to passively reread their notes. No editing. No reorganizing. No supplementing. Just reading what they had already written. Under those conditions, of course longhand notes performed better as a review product – they already contained generative features like paraphrasing and images baked in from the encoding phase. Laptop notes, full of verbatim transcription, offered little additional cognitive benefit from a simple reread. Also, both the learning and the study phases happened back to back. There may be a few situations in which students are tested immediately following exposure to new information but such situations are not where the major portion of student grades are determined.

But this isn’t how students use notes in practice. The laptop note taker’s comprehensive, transcription-heavy notes aren’t a finished product – they’re a first draft intended to be a first draft revisited over time. First drafts are meant to be revised and complete notes allow both further exploration and are more likely to be meaningful after a delay of days and weeks.

The Laptop’s Advantage

Here’s what’s ironic about the study’s findings: the very feature it criticizes – the completeness of laptop notes – is actually a significant advantage when students are allowed to modify their notes and revist them after multi-day delays.

Research on note modification consistently shows that students who revise, reorganize, and elaborate on their notes achieve more than students who simply review them passively. And the richer the initial record, the more material students have to work with during revision. Laptop note-takers, with their more complete capture of lecture content, have a larger, more detailed foundation for generative processing after the fact.

Moreover, laptops offer affordances for modification that longhand simply cannot match. Affordances is a term researchers like to use to refer to possibilities a system makes available. When you have a more complete body of content to work with and this content can easily be reorganized and extended. The generative activity can occur when the learner is less challenged with a rapid input of information and has time to reflect and maybe recall other bits and pieces (a reason reviewing your notes after class is useful). 

This study did note that laptop note takers recorded far fewer images than longhand note takers, and this contributed to lower achievement on image-related test items. But this deficit is entirely addressable. Students can take screenshots of lecture slides, paste in diagrams, or create their own visual representations during a modification phase. I acquired this approach while attending conference sessions, and I was surprised when my own students seemed unaware that it was allowed. After being frequently asked to wait so students could draw something from one of my PowerPoint slides into their notes, I offered this advice. I also just made my slides available in our course management system, but that is an entirely separate issue regarding the consequences this practice has. Maybe in another post. The fact that they didn’t capture images in real time doesn’t mean those images are lost forever. 

It’s Not About the Medium—It’s About the Strategy

Perhaps the most important insight from note-modification research is this: the debate between laptop and longhand is entirely the wrong debate. What matters isn’t the tool students use to take notes – it’s the strategy they employ before, during, and after note-taking.

The Luo et al. study captured students using their default, untrained behaviors. Laptop users defaulted to transcription because they could. Longhand users defaulted to selectivity and paraphrasing because they had to. Neither group was taught how to take notes strategically, and neither group was given the opportunity to do anything meaningful with their notes afterward.

When students are trained in effective note-taking and modification strategies, the medium effect largely disappears. A laptop user who transcribes during the lecture and then spends time paraphrasing, reorganizing, and adding visual representations is engaging in just as much – if not more – generative processing as a longhand user who paraphrased during encoding but never revisits the notes.

What This Means for Students and Educators

The research isn’t wrong about what it measured. But what it measured isn’t what students actually experience. Any study that freezes the note-taking process at the moment of initial recording and calls it complete is telling only half the story. And in education, half the story can lead to entirely the wrong conclusions. Read the Methods section or follow education bloggers who do. 

Reference

Luo, L., Kiewra, K., Flanigan, A., and Peteranetz, M. (2018). Laptop versus longhand note taking: Effects on lecture notes and achievement. Instructional Science 46(6), 947-971.

Loading

Building Better Note-Taking Skills in Elementary and Middle School Students: Research-Backed Strategies for Educators

Note-taking is a foundational skill that supports comprehension, retention, and critical thinking. However, many students below high school age struggle to develop effective note-taking habits on their own. There is comparatively little research on the development of note-taking skills in K12 compared to higher education, and within K12, the development of note-taking skills in elementary and middle schools receives extremely little attention. Still, from typically fourth grade on, it is commonly accepted that the goal in reading skills switches from learning to read to reading to learn. 

While I have always been interested in note-taking research and practice, my wife and I worked with a second-grade teacher to explore our early ideas about the creation of multimedia projects as learning opportunities. Pam Carlson, our elementary teacher colleague, was preparing her students to participate in what we called the butterfly project, in which they were learning about the life stages of butterflies, migration, and other relevant topics related to butterflies. Students were creating a HyperCard stack to share what they had learned, and each student selected a specific butterfly to describe in the card they created for the stack. In reviewing various books Pam provided students as resources, she offered the following instructions to guide the information students wrote down. When you find something you want to include, she suggested, think about that information carefully and then turn your book over so you will write down what you learned without copying from the book. I could rephrase her instructions in the way researchers would describe the goals of her required strategy (summarization, personalization, generative processing, etc.) when I taught or wrote about note-taking, but these concrete instructions still pop into my memory when I address the topic.

This post summarizes the few studies I was able to locate that I thought would be relevant to educators who work with younger students and I will try to describe what seems to me to be the implications for classroom implementation. As always, more work is needed. One basic observation that probably seems obvious to most educators, the studies I reference here, Ilter (2017), Lee et al. (2013), and Chang & Ku (2014), highlight the importance of explicit instruction and scaffolded strategies to help young learners master note-taking skills. An interesting generality about note-taking seems to be that while nearly all learners take notes in some form or another, few of any age experience direct instruction and evaluation of this important skill. 

Below, you will find key recommendations from these studies to help educators guide their young students toward becoming capable note-takers.

1. Explicit and Scaffolded Instruction of Note-Taking Strategies

One of the most important takeaways from the research is that note-taking skills should not be left to chance. Ilter (2017) emphasizes the need for early and explicit instruction in note-taking, starting in elementary school. Students often lack the intuitive ability to identify key information or organize their notes effectively, so educators must provide clear guidance.

Scaffolding is a critical component of this instruction. As the word implies, scaffolds are supports offering structure. A partial outline makes a reasonable example. Teachers should begin by modeling note-taking strategies and gradually shift responsibility to students as they gain confidence. For example, early lessons might involve guided practice with teacher feedback, while later lessons encourage students to take notes independently. This gradual release of responsibility ensures that students build the skills they need to succeed on their own.

2. Writing in Their Own Words

One of the biggest challenges for young students is avoiding verbatim copying. As I previously mentioned, Pam Carlson’s strategy for her second-grade students is noteworthy. Ilter (2017) and Lee et al. (2013) stress the importance of teaching students to paraphrase information in their own words. This practice not only improves comprehension but also helps students engage more deeply with the material. A related skill was brevity. One researcher liked the label “terse”. So, the goal was not just to paraphrase, but to focus on key or interesting ideas. 

To support this skill, educators can:

  • Model how to paraphrase by thinking aloud during lessons. A think-aloud is simply an effort to externalize your thinking. It is a common strategy suggested to help learners get a grasp on mental behaviors they cannot see. 
  • Provide practice exercises where students rewrite sentences or paragraphs in their own words.
  • Emphasize the value of organizing information logically, rather than simply copying it.

By focusing on paraphrasing and organization, students can develop a more meaningful understanding of the material they are studying.

3. Guided and Partial Graphic Organizers

Lee et al. (2013) highlight the benefits of using guided notes and partial graphic organizers to support young learners. Researchers often use the label “scaffolding” to describe this strategy. The goal is to offer guidance and reduce the “cognitive load” beginners face with a new skill. These tools reduce cognitive load by helping students focus on the most important information, rather than trying to capture everything at once.

For example:

  • Provide students with partially completed notes that include blanks for them to fill in during a lesson.
  • Use written prompts to guide students in identifying main points, summarizing content, and organizing their notes.

These strategies are particularly effective for elementary students, who may struggle to process and record information simultaneously. By reducing the mental effort required, guided notes and graphic organizers allow students to concentrate on understanding the material.

4. Focusing on Key Ideas, Keywords, and Text Structures

Chang & Ku (2014) emphasize the importance of teaching students to identify and use key ideas, keywords, and text structures in their notes. Their research with 4th graders provides several practical strategies for educators:

  • Highlighting Main Ideas: Teach students to use titles, headings, and guiding questions to identify the most important information in a text.
  • Recognizing Keywords: Help students identify function words like “however,” “because,” and “therefore,” which signal relationships between ideas.
  • Using Visual Aids: Introduce charts, diagrams, and other visual tools to represent similarities, differences, and other relationships. For example, how are moths and butterflies the same and different?
  • Analyzing Text Structures: Teach students to recognize organizational patterns, such as sequences or classifications. Is the author describing the steps in a process or the characteristics of a phenomenon or concept you should list in your notes.

These strategies not only improve the quality of students’ notes but also enhance their ability to understand and retain information.

5. Practice and Feedback

Finally, practice and feedback are essential for developing strong note-taking skills. Ilter (2017) recommends providing students with ample opportunities to practice taking notes independently. This practice should be paired with regular feedback from teachers and peers to help students refine their techniques.

For example:

  • After a lesson, ask students to share their notes with a partner and discuss what they found most important.
  • Provide specific feedback on how students can improve their notes, such as by adding more keywords or organizing information more clearly.
  • Encourage students to revise their notes based on feedback and reflect on what they learned.

By creating a supportive environment where students can practice and receive constructive feedback, educators can help them build confidence and competence in their note-taking abilities.

The Integrated Process

Itar suggests a sequence educators can follow in working with students to develop these skills. 

The Five-Step Instructional Model for Note-Taking

Ilter (2017) introduces a structured five-step approach to teaching note-taking, which can be applied to both reading and listening tasks. This model provides a clear framework for students to follow, making the process of taking notes more manageable and effective.

Step 1: Identify the Main Idea

Students should learn to highlight or underline important information and paraphrase it in their own words. Teaching them to use textual clues, such as headings or topic sentences, can help them pinpoint the main idea without resorting to verbatim copying.

Step 2: Information Reduction

Encourage students to condense paragraphs into essential points. This step helps them avoid excessive copying and focus on the most critical information.

Step 3: Keyword Identification

Teach students to recognize keywords that signal relationships between ideas, such as “because,” “however,” or “finally.” These words can help students understand the structure of the information and create meaningful connections in their notes.

Step 4: Use of Representations

Introduce visual tools like symbols, charts, diagrams, or graphic organizers to help students organize their notes. These representations make it easier to see relationships between ideas and improve recall.

Step 5: Analysis of Text Structures

Help students recognize text structures, such as headings, subheadings, sequences, and classifications. Understanding these structures allows students to organize their notes more effectively and see how different pieces of information fit together.

Summary

This post is intended as an extension of my previous posts on note-taking focused on academic settings and younger learners. Beginning in approximately fourth grade, learners both read to learn and listen to brief teacher presentations. The skills of taking notes is an important life skill seldom directly taught to learners of any age. Researchers are proposing and describing how elementary and middle school teachers can help students begin to develop these skills. 

References

Chang, W., & Ku, Y. (2014). The effects of note-taking skills instruction on elementary students’ reading. The Journal of Educational Research, 108(4), 278–291.

Ilter, I. (2017). Notetaking skills instruction for development of middle school students’ notetaking performance. Psychology in the Schools, 54(6), 596-611

Lee, P., Lan, W., Hamman, D. & Hendricks, B. (2008). The effects of teaching notetaking strategies on elementary students’ science learning. Instructional Science, 36(3), 191–201.

Loading