LLM Thinking Fast and Slow

Understanding how the AI you use most often actually works is a challenge for all of us. I recently read Ethan Mollick’s new book (Co-Existence) that offered an observation I found interesting, and I think I was able to test.  Mollick suggested that an AI tool could think either fast or slow. The way to explore the difference is what I want to describe here.

You may have encountered this distinction and not known what the options implied. For example, I use Readwise to archive the highlights and notes I create while reading Kindle and Apple Books. Readwise includes an AI chat feature that lets you interact with the stored content. The image below shows the interface for this feature. You can toggle between “Fast” and “Thinking” as alternate ways you want AI to respond to a prompt. This option didn’t make sense to me until I understood it as one way of acting on the distinction Mollick identified.

Fast and Slow Thinking in Humans

Daniel Kahneman wrote an influential book on this topic. 

One take away from Kahneman’s Fast and Slow Thinking is that we have a tendency to be cognitively lazy. The way we use AI may be similar. With AI, we often accept prompt replies as fine, but we could demand better and deeper responses. We accept lazy responses from AI and it could do better.

Kahneman’s fast thinking is automatic, intuitive, and quick involving mostly pattern recognition without the purposeful use of effortful cognition. Slow thinking is deliberate, effortful, and analytical. For example, seeing a familiar word and reading it without effort is fast thinking. Carefully working through a complex arithmetic problem is slow thinking. Fast thinking can create problems when it involves the application of stereotypes or problems such as confirmation bias – seeing what we want to see. Slow thinking, when unnecessary, wastes time and attention. 

Our metacognition (cognitive oversight and control) offers the opportunity to override the tendency for fast thinking. For example, I have written on several occasions that research findings show taking notes by hand is superior to taking notes on a keyboard, based on the desirable difficulty hypothesis. The claim is that people can type faster than they can write and when typing is available, they tend to record verbatim information rather than use more constructive processes such as summarization. If you consider this claim carefully, you might wonder why, if typing is easier and faster, a person using a keyboard does not take advantage by using these opportunities to also summarize and analyze. Verbatim recording is not required. Sometimes, without insight and training, people may ignore opportunities that are right in front of them. I will claim we may ignore a similar opportunity when prompting AI.

More than retrieval – reasoning with an LLM

It is difficult for most of us to understand how an LLM does what it does. Mollick suggests we may think that responses to a prompt are just an improved version of search. However, you or I understand the abstract nature of the “understanding” embedded in an LLM, Mollick proposes that retrieving answers to prompts (questions) is really the lower limit of what AI can provide. Even when the discovery of patterns in data available for retrieval that we have previously not identified can be quite surprising, but even then is pattern discovery all there is? When we use a word like reasoning, is that different and can LLMs reason? 

Mollick proposes that what we call reasoning is a process involving multiple components that go beyond a pattern-recognition summary. LLMs trained with reinforcement learning can take a multi-step approach that resembles the following.

  1. Identify the question and any assumptions that need examination. 
  2. Break the problem into its major components. 
  3. Consider plausible alternative explanations or interpretations. 
  4. Evaluate the evidence and distinguish established facts from inferences.
  5. Look for counterexamples, contradictions, and weaknesses in the reasoning. 
  6. Check important factual claims against reliable sources when appropriate. 
  7. Provide a concise conclusion that reflects the strength and limitations of the evidence.

For example, here is how I might prompt AI to address the handwriting vs. keyboarding controversy I use in many of my examples.

Instead of asking:

What does the research say about whether handwritten notes produce better learning than typed notes?

Ask:

Conduct a critical analysis of research comparing handwritten and typed note-taking. Identify the major studies, distinguish immediate recall from delayed learning, examine the quality of the research designs, consider competing explanations, identify limitations, and explain where the evidence supports firm conclusions versus tentative ones. Cite the original research where possible.

The second prompt defines what a satisfactory analysis requires. It encourages deeper work rather than simply a longer response.

Require independent verification.

You might also ask the AI to check its answer against original sources, recalculate numerical results, test competing explanations, or look for counterexamples. For research questions, this is particularly valuable because a convincing summary can conceal we

One final example created in a different way

You could fashion a prompt yourself, but some AI tools will understand a request to think and analyze before responding, doing something similar to what I outlined. I wanted to show the difference between what AI can do when thinking fast and slow. I was  using the local AI I have running on my Mac mini and stumbled upon the following demonstration. I first prompted the tool to explain the difference between fast and slow AI functioning. I then followed up by asking the AI to demonstrate the difference it had just described with a request I would specify. Finally, I asked for a description of the difference in what the two approaches involved. The following takes you through this sequence

Prompt: Explain how an AI tool thinks fast and slow. 

Let me think about how to explain this simply: 

Traditional LLMs: quick, direct answers, like a fast talker

Reasoners: slower, more thoughtful, like someone who thinks before speaking I need to capture the essence: internal reasoning chain vs. immediate generation, better performance on complex tasks, trade-off with speed.

Prompt: Show me what you are doing as you apply each approach.

Demonstrate this difference with the topic – what challenges to the economy would a democratic majority in the upcoming election produce

To illustrate the difference, here is how both approaches tackle a complex, politically nuanced question:

1. Traditional LLM Approach (Direct Pattern Completion)

How it works internally: The model predicts words sequentially based on common correlations in its training data without pausing to deliberate or structure an outline.

Output:

A Democratic majority could introduce several economic challenges, primarily centered around fiscal policy, taxation, and regulatory enforcement. Key concerns often raised by economists and market analysts include:

Corporate and High-Earner Tax Increases: Proposals to raise the federal corporate income tax rate and increase capital gains taxes could reduce corporate net margins, potentially dampening domestic capital investment and research spending.

Regulatory Burdens and Energy Transition Costs: Stricter labor regulations, environmental compliance standards, and aggressive decarbonization mandates can raise compliance overhead and production costs for legacy energy, manufacturing, and transportation sectors.

National Debt and Inflationary Pressure: Substantial federal investments in social infrastructure, climate initiatives, and entitlement expansions could widen fiscal deficits if spending outpaces new revenue, potentially putting upward pressure on interest rates.

2. AI Reasoner Approach (Chain-of-Thought & Critical Deliberation)

What happens during its internal reasoning chain before responding:

[Reasoning Phase – Internal Thinking]

1. Intent & Scope:

   – Topic: Economic challenges resulting from a Democratic majority.

   – Requirement: Detail potential downsides while remaining analytically objective and grounded in mainstream economic theory.

2. Disentangling Policy Levers:

   – Tax side: Higher statutory corporate rates (e.g., 21% -> 28%), top marginal brackets, capital gains revisions.

     * Mechanism: Impact on cost of capital, investment decisions, corporate tax incidence (wages vs. returns).

   – Regulatory side: FTC/DOJ antitrust posture, labor market rules (PRO Act provisions, overtime expansion), climate mandates.

     * Mechanism: Heightened compliance costs, friction in M&A/deal-making, energy transition friction.

   – Fiscal/Monetary interaction: High spending priorities vs. deficit targets in an era of higher baseline interest rates.

3. Distinguishing Immediate Market Shocks vs. Structural Headwinds:

   – Short-term: Equity market re-pricing due to anticipated margin compressions and regulatory scrutiny.

   – Long-term: Potential dampening of private R&D vs. productivity gains from public infrastructure.

4. Filtering & Refinement:

   – Ensure arguments represent recognized fiscal and economic perspectives (e.g., CBO, Tax Foundation, macro consensus) rather than purely partisan talking points.

   – Synthesize logically from immediate market frictions to long-term macroeconomic impacts.

Output:

If a Democratic majority takes control of both the executive and legislative branches, the primary economic challenges would stem from the structural shift toward higher public-sector intervention, progressive taxation, and stricter market oversight:

>Marginal Cost of Capital and Private Investment: Legislative proposals typically emphasize raising the corporate statutory tax rate (e.g., from 21% toward 28%) and reforming international tax frameworks. From an economic perspective, these measures reduce corporate after-tax returns, which can disincentivize domestic capital expenditure, prompt capital reallocation, and compress corporate profit margins.

Frictional Costs of Decarbonization and Sector-Specific Transitions: Accelerated regulatory enforcement—particularly through tighter EPA standards, limits on fossil fuel extraction, and clean energy mandates—tends to increase near-term input costs for energy, utilities, and transportation. While intended to achieve environmental sustainability, these policies can generate supply-side friction and transitional energy price volatility before renewable capacity fully scales.

> M&A Friction and Heightened Regulatory Oversight: A Democratic administration generally maintains an aggressive antitrust and labor posture (e.g., via the FTC, DOJ, and NLRB). Tighter scrutiny over mergers, stricter labor union protections, and expanded worker classification rules can raise corporate compliance overhead and slow consolidation in sectors like technology, healthcare, and retail.

> Sovereign Debt Burden in a Higher-Yield Environment: Ambitious spending programs aimed at the social safety net, housing subsidies, and healthcare expansion risk exacerbating structural budget deficits. In an economic climate where baseline Treasury yields and borrowing costs are elevated, higher sovereign debt issuance can crowd out private borrowing and constrain future fiscal flexibility.

Show my adjustments the reasoner approach made as it worked 

Here is a look “under the hood” at the specific adjustments, course corrections, and self-checks the reasoner makes while formulating the response:

1. Tone Correction: Removing Partisan Rhetoric

First Instinct: The model initially recalls common political debate points, such as *”crippling business growth with anti-corporate penalties”* or *”reckless social spending causing rampant inflation.”*

The Reasoner’s Correction: Recognizes that value-laden words sound biased rather than analytical. It swaps subjective rhetoric for precise economic terminology:

  * *Drafted thought:* “Businesses will stop investing because taxes are too high.”

  * *Adjusted to:* “Higher corporate statutory rates increase the marginal cost of capital, potentially disincentivizing private capital expenditure.”

2. Disentangling Policy from Economic Mechanisms

 **First Instinct:** Simply listing Democratic platform items (e.g., green subsidies, raising the minimum wage, student loan relief).

**The Reasoner’s Correction:** Realizes a list of policies is not an explanation of *economic challenges*. It traces each policy to its secondary transmission channel:

  * *Drafted thought:* “They want stricter climate regulations and electric vehicle mandates.”

  * *Adjusted to:* Traces the supply-chain friction—identifying how rapid regulatory changes increase near-term input costs for heavy industry and utilities before cleaner alternatives reach full scale.

 3. Factoring in Current Macroeconomic Realities

**First Instinct:** Treat government borrowing in the abstract (e.g., “Deficits increase the national debt”).

* **The Reasoner’s Correction:** Grounds the critique in today’s higher interest-rate climate rather than the near-zero-rate environment of previous decades:

  * *Drafted thought:* “More spending increases the national debt.”

  * *Adjusted to:* Evaluates how deficit-financed programs interact with higher baseline Treasury yields, highlighting the risk of crowding out private credit and escalating debt servicing costs.

4. Structuring for Analytical Depth Rather Than Breadth

**First Instinct:** Try to touch on every possible friction point (healthcare rules, immigration policy, trade tariffs, tech regulation, banking scrutiny).

**The Reasoner’s Correction:** Recognizes that covering ten disparate areas leads to a superficial, shallow list. It clusters related factors into four core structural pillars:

  1. *Capital & Investment* (tax structure and incentives)

  2. *Supply-Side Transition Costs* (energy and environment)

  3. *Operational & Transaction Frictions* (labor rules and antitrust)

  4. *Macroeconomic & Fiscal Constraints* (sovereign debt and rates)

Summary of the Shift

“`

[Superficial Surface Association]

“Democrats spend money and raise taxes -> bad for businesses and causes debt.”

                                ?

[Reasoner’s Internal Adjustments]

• Strip partisan spin ? use economic theory (cost of capital, compliance drag)

• Trace indirect effects ? explain the *mechanism* of transition friction

• Account for macro environment ? evaluate debt in an elevated-interest-rate regime

                                ?

[Refined Output]

Structured, objective analysis focused on capital allocation, regulatory friction, and fiscal mechanics.

*****

For a further discussion of Fast and Slow AI try thus blog post from Precision Weave. 

Loading

Less Expensive Equipment Alone Won’t Take Down Chromebooks

I have been an Apple in education guy since the 1980s. The potential of the new NEO for that market immediately caught my attention. So many podcasts have speculated about the potential of the Neo in the marketplace and one of the participants on Macbreak Weekly changed my mind concerning the Neo as a Chromebook killer. She argued that the price point of the Neo or lower-end iPads is only part of what the school-based tech people consider. Apple or Microsoft has no viable alternative to Google Classroom and the structure and security issues addressed are worth a lot to school tech decision makers. 

How popular are different tech products in K12?

You might think providing data on the recent history of school purchases of Apple, Windows, and Chromebook devices would be simple. Some source must have found this topic to be of interest. I have tough expectations for what this would look like with Chromebooks showing a sharp rise in recent years. What I was less certain I understood was the comparative tracks of Apple and Windows equipment. I have been retired now for about a decade so I have spent only a little time in schools. I expected popularity comparisons would show Apple somewhere between Chromebook and Windows machines. 

There are no “official statistics,” and some of the most carefully acquired have value to businesses interested in the education market, and require you to purchase the reports (e.g., Futuresource). Data I could locate was inconsistent and no source fit my expectations. After multiple searches, I asked Perplexity to generate a graph for the 20 year period I wanted and that graph appears below. I did find similar general descriptions elsewhere to my surprise and the issue here is whether the new and less expensive Apple computer will change this trend. 

Why Chromebooks will likely continue the tech of choice?

So, Google’s Chromebooks have maintained a stranglehold on K-12 classrooms. While the Neo is a device that brings the prestige and power of macOS to a price point that schools can actually afford, the decisions those who make purchases depend on more than the cost of the equipment. 

The real reason Chromebooks will likely still be preferred isn’t just the lower price tag; it is the infrastructure of Google Classroom and the Google Workspace for Education ecosystem. Until Apple builds a direct, functional competitor to Google Classroom, the Neo is just a nice laptop in a room where everyone is already tied into a different system.

When a school district buys a large number of devices, often in the thousands, they are looking beyond a reasonable price point and hardware sophistication. Organizations also consider manageability and deployability – how to oversee how devices are used and how to set them up quickly and efficiently. Apple has always focused on individual users. When the machine assigned to an individual has an issue or selects one from a classroom card, each student simply signs in to the new machine, it is personalized, tabs, documents, and settings like the last time they connected. The design of Apple equipment maintains an individual’s priorities and content on that individual’s machine. 

The Google Classroom

Google Classroom was designed with an understanding of the school day and classroom tasks. It connects to Google’s online services – Google Drive, Calendar, and Meet and gives the teacher some level of immediate access to student accounts. Teachers have a way to distribute and grade assignments. Google Classroom allows a teacher to “make a copy for each student” with one click, see real-time progress on an essay, and provide instant feedback. The system works great because Google owns both the productivity suite (Docs/Sheets) and the management layer (Classroom).

Built for Collaboration

Google Docs was built for the web and for collaboration; it was built for twenty students to be in the same document at the same time without the system crashing or creating “conflicted copies.” Students can peer-edit, work on group slides, and share data in real-time. These capabilities can be accessed on the devices from other companies, but if classroom tasks are heavily dominated by tasks Google makes easy why add the complications of equipment that is not as easily integrated? 

The Cost Issue at the Level of the System

As I understand it, Google Classroom itself is generally provided at no additional cost to schools as part of Google Workspace for Education. The cost of Google Workspace depends on what schools want. There is a free tier for eligible institutions that provides the core tools such as Docs, Drive, Gmail, and Meet. Schools can also pay for other features that meet common needs, such as advanced security, analytics, admin controls, and additional teacher tools. I couldn’t find pricing details as the charge to the schools depends on the number of classrooms and teachers. 

Additional Comments

Teachers don’t choose platforms; districts do. Procurement decisions happen at the IT/admin level, not the classroom level. In considering Apple versus Microsoft in the business environment, the same issue seems to apply. In schools. Google won those relationships early and aggressively in the 2010s, and switching costs are now enormous — not technically, but now in terms of retraining staff and migrating years of curriculum materials. It seems to me Windows and Apple equipment will continue to have value in specific school applications but overcoming the inertia of a device and services suited to the most common tasks would be a massive challenge. If we get to AI on devices, perhaps things will change. 

Other companies have attempted to develop competing services. For example, Microsoft has Teams for Education. This product is regarded as capable, but teachers reportedly find Google Classroom much easier to use. 

Summary

Understanding why schools adopt a given type of tech hardware may not be as apparent as some may assume. This post argues that even given a similar price point other factors are important and Google has a lead when it comes to the basics of common classroom practice. 

Loading

The Rise and Fall of the Twitter EdChat

For over a decade, the hashtag #Edchat allowed educators using Twitter to gather, share, and commiserate. However, as the platform formerly known as Twitter transitioned into X, the landscape of this digital discussion site shifted dramatically. Drawing from recent research, this post explores how educators have used #Edchat over time, the stressors inherent in this social media use, and the history of a community in transition. Researchers understand that for a variety of reasons, Twitter and Twitter chats are far less influential than they were a few years ago. They argue that studying the edchat phenomenon historically may have value for other social media platforms generally and specifically, should they hope to involve educators. 

The Golden Era of #Edchat: Purpose and Participation

In its prime, #Edchat provided a means for informal professional development. Research by Willet (2019) and later Willet and colleagues analyzed hundreds of thousands of tweets to understand exactly how and why educators were using the platform. The study identified several key types of engagement:

  • Resource Sharing: The most common use case, where teachers curated and distributed lesson plans, EdTech tools, links, and articles.
  • Pedagogical Debate: Scheduled weekly chats allowed for deep dives into specific topics, from classroom management to the integration of AI.
  • Social Support: Perhaps most importantly, it provided a space for “digital social support,” helping teachers feel less isolated in their professional struggles.

This era was defined by a sense of “augmented intelligence,” in which the collective knowledge of the network enhanced individual teachers’ expertise.

2008–2014: The Golden Era of Synchronous Twitter Connection

The #Edchat phenomenon began in October 2008. This early era was defined by the weekly Tuesday night chat, a highly structured synchronous event that became a must for thousands of educators. An agreement on Tuesday night did not result from any official declaration, but once started, Tuesday night became the default for those wanting to participate in a common chat. 

I encourage anyone interested in the topic of teacher use of social media to read the two references to Willet and colleagues I provide here. These researchers had access to what I have heard described as the Twitter firehose, which was available until 2023, and downloaded over 15 million tweets for analysis using the #edchat hashtag as used over 15 years. Unlike researchers who implemented projects of a much smaller scale and made use of human raters to classify and quantify characteristics of such chats, Willet and colleagues used data analysis tools that quantified specific characteristics (questions, responses, links, secondary tags, retweets) and even tools that attempted to identify themes based on terms appearing in the tweets. These characteristics were mapped against years to identify trends.

This approach allowed certain questions that could only be addressed by this massive scale. What trends could be observed over the history of the edchat phenomenon, but may have been overlooked in the data? For example, the way in which edchats evolved interacted with the capabilities of the Twitter platform. Tags were a user-applied innovation that was later integrated into the tool as a capability. Tuesday night became the impromptu time for edchats, which took on a formalized approach. A chat leader would provide a series of prompts identified as Q1, Q2, Q… and participants would respond using R1,R2, R… . Other tweets could be added within the rough synchronous time frame defined by the prompts. Because chats were stored, others might review the session at their leisure and add their own contributions. 

Just to be clear for those unfamiliar with the reason for this format, this experience was based on a kludge of sorts. By searching for #edchat, you could follow the sequence of questions, responses, and related comments in real time, separate from other Twitter chatter. The hashtag functions as a sort of portal, focusing Twitter use on the chat content and turning Twitter from an asynchronous to a synchronous tool. Tools other than Twitter, such as Tweetdeck (no longer available), even allowed users to create a multi-column display, with individual columns focused on specific tags and updated automatically. Only the #echat contributions would then be displayed within one column. These tools became popular as an easy way to turn the Twitter feed into a synchronous experience unique to those using the #edchat hashtag. 

Research shows that between 2009 and 2014, these Tuesday sessions saw significantly higher engagement than other days, characterized by genuine dialogue and a high volume of questions and replies. Teachers weren’t just “knowledge telling”; they were building communities of practice and exploring new pedagogical ideas in real-time.

The researchers had a special interest in the frequency of questions and replies, and the ratio between the two, assuming these variables would be a good way to assess interaction. In addition, how did these variables differ between Tuesday and other days, assuming this would be related to the higher likelihood of synchronous interaction on Tuesdays? Replies made up a higher proportion on Tuesdays and were significantly higher in the earlier years. My interpretation differs from the researchers’. They argued that there was a decrease in interaction in later years. My interpretation is that the chats drifted away from the formal structure of questions interspersed with participants’ answers. Relying on the massive scale and automated methods employed rather than human raters following the give and take of individual sessions may have led to different interpretations. 

2014–2018: The Shift from Dialogue to Broadcasting

At its peak in 2017–2018, #Edchat was a massive digital footprint, averaging 120,000 tweets per month and involving roughly 200,000 different users. However, beneath these impressive numbers, the nature of the interaction was shifting. Starting around 2014, Willet and other researchers observed a transition from authentic conversation toward broadcast-style communication.

Several key trends marked this transformation:

• The Rise of the Link: While early chats focused on natural discussion, later years saw a sharp increase in posts containing hyperlinks to external content, suggesting the platform was becoming a repository for resource sharing rather than deep discussion.

• Retweet Dominance: Retweets began to outnumber original posts, and the percentage of questions receiving replies dropped significantly. Retweets could be used by individuals to bring those who followed these individuals but were not chat participants to experience the content.

• Exploitation: As the hashtag grew in popularity, it became a target for spam and self-promotion. By 2018, the community faced a spike in problematic content and a decline in “authenticity scores” as commercial interests exploited the tag for marketing.

The transition to less interaction and greater influencer dominance may also be related to the active/passive distinction that researchers have begun to study in social media activity. A focus on Twitter chats as a source of resources is consistent with this research topic.

You can still find the use of #edchat on X, Bluesky, and Mastodon instances. The tag is typically used now to indicate educational content and is seldom used in the same way within a chat sequence. A few chats can still be found, often now, using more idiosyncratic tags.

The Paradox of Digital Support

I wrote a series of posts beginning in 2013, focused on edchats, mostly questioning the information value of the process. I appreciated the camaraderie the chats offered, but the limit on the number of characters Twitter allowed, along with my reaction to the content included in such chats, led me to believe the experience was very inefficient, and I thus proposed tactics I thought would increase the professional development value of the experiences. 

Edchats were often included as one experience within the grad course on technology class I taught, and I proposed, without success, that students might analyze the content of such chats as a potential thesis project. My suggestion at that time was that video-based systems (e.g., Skype, Zoom) would allow a much more productive approach. 

2018–2023: Volatility, X, and Fragmentation

The decline of #Edchat accelerated after 2018, driven by platform volatility and the eventual transition of Twitter into X. Changes in leadership and algorithm priorities disrupted the organic reach of educational hashtags. As the environment became more polarized, many educators began to migrate to other platforms like Instagram, Mastodon, or niche, specialized communities that better served their specific needs.

By 2023, the once-unified #Edchat community had largely fragmented. This decline highlights a critical vulnerability: digital spaces on commercial platforms often lack the stability and continuity of traditional professional development. When profit extraction and algorithmic shifts override user experience, the community suffers.

Lessons for the Future

The history of #Edchat is a reminder that while platforms change, the human need for collaboration remains constant. The legacy of this 15-year experiment suggests that for future digital communities to succeed, they must:

1. Prioritize Active Participation: Moving beyond passive consumption is essential to avoid the stress of social comparison.

2. Foster Authentic Dialogue: Successful communities require mechanisms that encourage genuine interaction over simple content broadcasting.

3. Shift to Knowledge Building: The goal of any digital faculty lounge should be to move from merely “telling” knowledge to collaboratively building it.

Perhaps online interaction among educators isn’t gone; it is simply evolving. As educators move toward new tools, the story of #Edchat serves as both a testament to the power of digital connection and a cautionary tale about the challenges of sustaining authentic community in commercial environments.

I have tried to identify where those educators interested in online interaction with peers went. I could not find the type of quantified data provided by Willett, but other researchers (Greenhow and colleagues) have suggested that Facebook groups and Instagram have become favorite sites for interaction. 

Sources:

Greenhow, C., Galvin, S. M., Brandon, D. L., & Askari, E. (2020). A decade of research on K–12 teaching and teacher learning with social media: Insights on the state of the field. Teachers College Record, 122(6), 1-72.

Willet, K.  (2019). Revisiting how and why educators use Twitter: Tweet types and purposes in# Edchat. Journal of Research on Technology in Education, 51(3), 273-289.

Willet, K., Carpenter, J., & Na, H. (2025). Ex-Edchat: Historic retrospective of X/Twitter# Edchat. Computers & Education, 241, 1-18.

Loading

Evaluating the Consequences of School Choice

The education of learners in the K-12 range is undergoing a noticeable shift as the concept of “school choice” has become a political wedge issue, and state-level legislative policy decisions have given parents and their kids greater control over where and under what conditions students are educated. While often framed from a perspective of the individual family, I have always felt this perspective is too narrow and decisions made for the benefit of one benefit also impact the experiences of others. In various ways, we are all stakeholders, whether it be as citizens living in a society dependent on an educated population, financial contributors as state and local taxpayers, and students and their families involved in school experiences. 

While I have followed the issue of school choice for years, this post was prompted by a recent EdWeek article – As School Choice Goes Universal, What New Research Is Showing. Before I comment on the article, here is some background on K12 School Choice.

School choice is the opportunity for parents to enroll their child in an elementary or secondary school other than the assigned school based on their home address. There are multiple variations. The optional school may be another public school in a different district or a public magnet or charter school. Funding for charter schools, which typically operate with a separate board from the public school district, may be public or private. Private schools can be further differentiated as parochial (religious emphasis) or independent. 

My personal interest is mainly in the impact of tax-based funding as I see funding as a nearly zero-sum variable – schools compete for a fixed pot of money dependent on student enrollment. Private schools rely on tuition paid by families, contributions, and, increasingly, tax money collected and then distributed to the school in which the student is enrolled. When school choice sends tax money to a private school the approach may be as a voucher or a family-controlled educational savings account (ESA). A voucher might be thought of as the cut of tax money a school receives from the state – per pupil expenditure, but by my understanding typically not the local tax based on property taxes. An ESA provides funds parents can use for several forms of educational assistance – tutoring, textbooks, and private school tuition (source – Overview of Public and Private School Choice Options).

According to the EdWeek source I identified previously, 18 states now allow all students to use state funds to attend private schools, approximately 1.5 million students in the 30 states that allow at least some students access to similar programs. An example of the type of situation that accounts for the difference might be an allowance for students attending what are considered low-performing to use such resources.

My interest has been in the academic achievement of both students who leave their designated public school and a more nuanced issue of what happens to public schools when a sizeable number of students and the funds associated with these students leave. Despite all of the research on such topics, the EdWeek analysis notes that only one of the 18 states identified as providing all students access to state funds made use of the same standardized achievement test in both public and private schools. Obviously, having large numbers of participants from both public and private institutions taking the same tests would offer the cleanest and most powerful comparison of academic impact. 

Proposed advantages and disadvantages of each approach to K12 education

At present, the political winds seem to be blowing toward greater parental choice. This is the case despite the lack of consistent findings on whether such choice is of greater benefit to student achievement. Depending on the sample of students used and the method used to quantify achievement, studies generate every possible outcome. The EdWeek attempt at a summary concludes that “Preliminary studies on earlier iterations of these programs have shown “neutral to negative” effects on state test scores, though some programs, like Ohio’s EdChoice, have demonstrated positive outcomes regarding graduation and college-going rates.”

What follows is my attempt to summarize the advantages and disadvantages based on two books by Diane Ravitch that I have read. Dr. Ravitch is a defender of public education as you can probably tell from the titles of her books, but pros and cons are more about the arguments and not the data. Ravitch’s work is heavily focused on research findings, but as I have already indicated, the subissues are so complex that it is very difficult to offer general conclusions. The issue that interests me – what happens to the public schools when students leave (the final con described below under the cons of Private schools) has not, to my knowledge, been a focus as an appropriate methodology would be very difficult to put together. 

Pros of Public Schools:

  • Universal Service and Stability: Public schools are charged with serving all children, providing not just education but also essential social services like nutritious meals, medical care, and mental health counseling. 
  • Accountability and Transparency: Public schools operate under strict state regulations and testing mandates, ensuring a level of transparency regarding student progress and the use of taxpayer funds that can be absent in the private sector.
  • Professionalism: Public schools generally require higher standards for teacher certification and may provide due process (tenure) to protect academic freedom.

Cons of Public Schools:

  • Impact of Poverty and Segregation: The biggest “con” of the public system is often beyond its direct control. Concentrated poverty and racial segregation significantly drive lower academic performance, and schools alone cannot solve these structural societal issues.
  • Curriculum Narrowing: Due to high-stakes testing mandates, public schools may reduce time for the arts, history, and physical education to focus more on tested subjects like math and reading.
  • Bureaucracy and Funding Disparities: Public schools are often burdened by intrusive regulations and suffer from persistent underfunding, particularly in districts with low property tax bases.

Pros of Private Schools:

  • Autonomy and Flexibility: Private schools enjoy the freedom to design their own curricula and select their own testing methods, allowing them to cater to specific educational philosophies or religious values.
  • Personalization and Choice: Families can select schools that align with their specific needs or interests, whether through small religious schools or specialized academies. This “market-driven” approach appeals to values of freedom and optimism.

Cons of Private Schools:

  • Lack of Oversight: some private schools receiving public funds are not accredited and are exempt from state accountability systems. This makes it difficult for the public to evaluate if tax dollars are producing academic results.
  • Selective Enrollment: Unlike public schools, private institutions can be selective. Critics argue this leads to greater segregation and less equity, as schools may shun students with the highest needs or those who are the “toughest challenge” to teach.
  • Draining Public Resources: Every dollar diverted to a private school voucher is a dollar removed from the public school system, which still incurs fixed costs such as building maintenance and teacher salaries. This can lead to increased class sizes and program cuts in the remaining public schools.

Summary

Parents and their kids are being allowed greater control over where they attend school. School choice comes with multiple pros and cons, and these issues have been difficult to evaluate because public and private schools in most states are not required to use the same achievement tests. My personal interest is in what happens to the public schools that lose students to private schools when choice is allowed.

Sources for Pro and Con Section

Ravitch, D. (2014). Reign of error: The hoax of the privatization movement and the danger to America’s public schools. Vintage.

Ravitch, D. (2020). Slaying Goliath: The passionate resistance to privatization and the fight to save America’s public schools. Vintage.

Loading

RSS – Be Your Own Content Platform

Tim Wu, in his recent book, The Age of Extraction: How Tech Platforms Conquered the Economy and Threatened Our Future, examines the timeline of a variety of platforms and the manner in which they consistently morph from being initially attractive, innovative, and genuinely helpful resources into systems that become confining, controlling, and ultimately draining for their users. Using examples that range from Facebook and Amazon to UnitedHealth he argues that this transformation, from open utility to extractive gatekeeper, is not an accidental side effect, but rather a predictable, structural characteristic of platform business models as they achieve scale and market dominance.

In considering the examples from Wu’s book it occurred to me that while he emphasized the major players a wide variety of people use, the same issues apply to smaller platforms. Those of us who write and use platforms to share our work (e.g., Substack, Reddit, Medium) have likely experienced the same timeline. 

Many authors who write books with a similar message to The Age of Extraction do a great job of explaining the problem and its history, but even though they make an effort offer little as a remedy. I have read many such books. I typically find myself contemplating but failing to generate suggestions to augment what the author was able offer.

Like Wu, I bought into the original promise of the Internet as a leveling platform that would give content creators, sellers, and the “little guy” in general greater opportunities. In the early days (2002), I started a blog and did so from a server that was also my desktop computer (I worked at a University and had a dedicated IP which was more of the challenge than the ease with which any Mac could be used as a server). Things change. I now pay a hosting company a couple hundred dollars a year to allow me to run blog software and the related backend database and register my domain name. Still, as a hobby, once I pay for the space, I can function independently.

I believe the way we create and share content has changed. You can still do it, but it seems you have fewer and fewer regular readers. I have noticed a change that suggests more and more of my posts are read through search rather than by readers who regularly view the blog. I track hits out of curiosity and find little immediate interest in most posts. I check say a year or six months later and find that some posts have been read hundreds of times. Logically, I interpret this to mean I have written something that people found through search. I shouldn’t complain about this, but the switch from pure search to AI search now being developed by the big platforms means there will be far less attention to source material when an AI summary based on this homogenized and integrated material is made available. This is an emerging but I think obvious issue and a perfect example of what Wu means by platform extraction. 

The big switch (another book) to focus on extractive platforms has resulted from a) integrative platforms such as those I have already mentioned hosting multiple content creators and b) a related move away from the use of RSS readers by individual consumers. I certainly understand the benefits of single-stop platforms that provide a convenient way to reach a wide audience. My complaint is based on the history of these platforms. The pattern of extraction is evident. Start by offering a service in which the platform and content creators share in the risk and the rewards, and once a critical mass for a network effect is achieved, reduce the benefits to the producers and to the consumers. Wu suggests Amazon makes a familiar example of this approach.

I do post my content to one of these community platforms and continue to post the same content to my own blog. Yes, this means I pay twice and I continue to be frustrated by this situation. One approach allows me to own my content and the other to reach a larger audience – for a price.

My solutions:

I do have suggestions for an alternative approach, but I understand that each requires an effort that most consumers are unwilling to invest. You can be your own platform with easy-to-use tools.

Use Google Alerts – Yes Google is a big company, but it does offer some beneficial services. Google Alerts might be imagined as a period search process based on specific interests you specify. You provide a typical search request, then select how often you want to receive the results. Updates are sent to you in an email periodically according to the time intervals you request. I have multiple alerts that generate a week list of new content. In this approach, you are following a topic rather than specific content creators.

RSS is still around and modern readers make the process easy to implement. With RSS, you designate the sources (e.g., specific blogs) you want to follow, and an RSS reader accumulates new content generated by these sources. You check in to your reader when you have time and see what is new. Some contend that Google’s abandonment of its very popular Reader in 2013 signaled the end of this tool category, but more modern alternatives have since emerged. 

Yes, RSS readers do offer a subscription level and any provider realistically has costs. While the pro level offers great features, most users will find the free level meets their needs.

My preference is for web-based readers – the service is accessed through a browser rather than standalone apps. Feedly is my recommendation. I like Inoreader and Reeder (Apple) as apps. 

I have written more detailed descriptions elsewhere (Feedly, Inoreader) and you could consult these sources if you need more information. 

Summary

I didn’t really intend this post as a book review, but Tim Wu’s book is interesting and informative. As I suggested, the book identifies the typical timeline of extraction consumers should recognize and use to guide their decision making. Again, solutions, should that be what you are seeking, are not easy to imagine.

I think we have a classic “chicken and egg” problem with platforms versus independent sources. Content creators will go where their content is more likely to be consumed. Tools for sharing will exist and be improved where there are content creators and content consumers. 

For the great majority of creators and consumers, the motivation of income is deceptive and a trap. Most writers would seem better off thinking of their goal as visibility rather than profit. Writing for a platform for the vast majority should be treated as a hobby, recognizing the reality of being trapped by the network effect. 

Loading

The Decline in Reading Activities – Does it matter?

Lately, I have encountered several essays that examine possible connections between the claims that “few people, including students, read books anymore” and “the declining percentage of individuals moving through our educational systems who are competent readers” (see links to several of these articles included at the end of this post). To attract a general audience, this decline in reading proficiency is often framed as a concern for future international economic competitiveness. What caught my attention in this unexpected batch of essays was the claim that researchers had failed to provide evidence that differences in time spent reading, and more specifically in reading lengthy works, resulted in improved reading skills and related intellectual benefits. In several of these articles, it was claimed that such relationships had not been proven. I had to move beyond these secondary sources to primary sources to understand the bases for these claims, and then to explore further on my own to determine whether I agreed. Is the lack of interest in books a serious problem?

The low rate of reading proficiency in the U.S.

Reading skills are declining and this trend has been ongoing for years. This decline is evident in multiple tests used to assess reading skills, with the most attention likely given to the NAEP (National Assessment of Educational Progress), which compares the performance of U.S. students with that of students from other nations. Implications for economic productivity and international competitiveness are sure to catch the attention of the general public and politicians. 

The pattern of decline among U.S. students is notable: over the years, the less proficient have declined year by year, whereas the most skilled have not shown this trend and score at roughly the same level on the tests used to track reading skill. Among other issues, this means that the range of competence educators must address within a single grade level is increasing, thereby complicating instruction. Multiple factors potentially associated with this trend have been identified and such claims have provided ideas for remediation. Most of you have likely heard of the “science of reading” controversy, which in recent years has prompted greater emphasis on phonics. Screen time is often cited as a culprit in many areas, including reading. Recently, absenteeism has risen at an alarming rate and it seems logical that missing school for many days means students miss instruction. There are likely multiple causes for a general academic trend and these causes interact in ways that defy simple solutions. 

Recent changes in reading proficiency broken down by initial level of functioning.

Reading Skill and Reading Activity

Daniel Willingham, an educational expert I often cite, proposes a more straightforward explanation in claiming that the “main differentiating factor” between strong and weak readers is “the volume of reading they do,” because that’s how they build both reading skills and a rich background knowledge. The mention here of background knowledge should not be overlooked and requires a little more detail. Studies that differentiate background knowledge from reading skill demonstrate that background knowledge is more critical in predicting differences in what readers understand from what they read. Put another way if good and poor readers are also differentiated by what they already know about a topic (e.g., good readers with poor existing knowledge, poor readers with good existing knowledge), the difference in background knowledge is the better predictor of understanding and retention. So, what Willingham argues is that the amount of reading has a unique importance, possibly ignored in other discussions of the development not just reading skill, but the more general impact of reading as a component of learning more generally. 

It is not that time spent reading and its relationship has been ignored (see Allington & McGill-Franzen). Attempts to track the amount of reading students and adults spend have been recorded with great diligence. How many minutes, how many books, whether the reading is on a digital device or paper, how many books are available in the home, how frequently does an individual visit a library, does a family subscribe to a newspaper, and similar variables have been quantified and related to reading skill and potential moderating variables such as family income. These variables consistently relate to measures of reading skill, and because these measures of activity seem to be in decline, have been argued as possible causes of poorer reading skills.

Causal Relationship Between Activity and Performance

Allington and his colleague raise an interesting point as have other scholars I have recently read about why the amount of reading has not received more attention. Allington makes an observation that blames reading researchers, which I find interesting. He claims that researchers have difficulty explaining the observed relationship between time spent reading and reading skill, because this relationship has seldom been tested experimentally. This position should be presented to mean that the observed relationships are correlational. How can it be known if more reading alone builds reading skill when the data could also be interpreted to argue that more capable readers enjoy reading and read more? Why might this matter? Allington notes that elementary school reading instruction focuses far more time on skill development than on extended reading. Extended reading, often called free reading, allows students to use school time to read independently and would include basal reader time and library books.

Just to be clear, there are many topics of interest to scientists in other fields that involve limited “manipulative” research. When investigating factors we believe have negative consequences, scholars seldom create the unfavorable circumstances to determine whether those harmful consequences follow. Sometimes, potential causal relationships are analyzed through correlational techniques because the causes cannot be manipulated or would be extremely expensive to manipulate. 

Allington does provide two counterexamples to the claim that the amount of reading, and in these examples, the reading of books, cannot be manipulated. The first example involves the gifting of books to randomly selected children through existing programs (e.g., the Dolly Parton Imagination Library) and the subsequent administration of follow-up assessments. The second employed a similar approach, focusing on the “summer slide” in reading performance among children from low-income families. Again, in selecting participants at random and comparing the selected group with non-selected individuals based on a gifted home library for the summer on a follow-up assessment. In both cases, greater access to books was associated with higher reading proficiency scores. The random assignment of access to the gifted books allows for a more persuasive argument for causality.

Voluntary vs Required, Intensive vs Extensive

The topic I have presented here has a number of subtopics that are relevant, but examining these issues should probably be pursued in other posts. The voluntary vs required distinction relates to reading set in a formal education setting or pursued without direction outside of the classroom. Voluntary reading at any age has consequences. The difference between intensive and extensive reading is relevant to a variety of issues that relate to reading for different purposes (research papers, technical manuals vs books) differ in potential benefits. When it comes to the amount read, does a number of shorter pieces generate the same impact as a book, or are there unique skills involved when persistence is required, and relevant pieces necessary for understanding are spaced over greater units of time?  This issue is relevant to the different type of reading most of us might do online.

Resources

Academic sources:

Allington, R. & McGill-Franzen, A. (2021). Reading volume and reading achievement: A review of recent research. Reading Research Quarterly, 56, S231-S238.

Abdurakhmonova, Z., & Pardayeva, R. (2025). Exploring intensive and extensive reading. International Conference on Culture & History. 1(3), 34-38.

Gioia, D. (2008). To read or not to read: A question of national consequence. Diane Publishing.

Willingham, D. T. (2017). The reading mind: A cognitive approach to understanding how the mind reads. John Wiley & Sons.

News sources addressing the decline in the popularity of reading books

Kids Rarely Read Whole Books Anymore 

Whole books or excerpts: Which does the most to promote reading ability –

Novels vs. excerpts: What to know about a big reading debate 

Loading

Word processing: Desirable difficulty or  opportunities get taken

When it comes to how we use technology, familiarity can limit analysis and exploration. I started thinking about this challenge when encountering the work of an academic who has examined the history of word processing. When I first wrote about word processing in the 1990s, the issues were similar to current topics of whether students should read from paper or screen and whether it was better to take notes on paper or on a laptop. There were comparisons of which method was more productive and efforts to account for the advantages that were identified. It was once similar with word processing. Should students learn to write on paper or using a computer? What were the advantages and disadvantages of each approach? How might the instruction of writing skills with computers be modified to take advantage of the unique capabilities of a digital approach? My thought is that many are now no longer aware of these questions and conclusions and that personal practice and instructional emphases may ignore key findings. This concern seems especially relevant given the new issues raised by the use of AI in writing and learning to write.

I decided to write again about this topic after listening to an interview with Matthew Kirschenbaum on the “This Week in Tech” network’s “Intelligent Machines” podcast focused on Kirschenbaum’s recent focus on the role of AI in writing and learning to write. The podcast guest was a member of the  Modern Languages Association (MLA) panel, generating what are likely to become several influential position papers on learning to write and AI. This interview, which makes up maybe the first half hour of the podcast, is worth the attention of any educator trying to make sense of how AI will impact schools and universities. As part of the brief introduction of the podcast guest, Krischenbaum it was noted that the guest had recently written “Trach Changes: Literary History of Word Processing”.As I suggested, word processing had been a personal interest so I did purchase and read the book.

It wasn’t that the book wasn’t well written, but I did struggle to get through it. The podcast focus resulted in my misunderstanding of the topic of the book. The history of the transition from writing on paper and typewriter was of some interest, because I lived through that transition and the mention of technology hardware and software and the required skills involved in writing with a computer brought back plenty of memories. I was less interested in which noted author had made his or her transition from a notepad or typewriter to a word processor during their career. Concerns of the reading community related to how technology might influence literature likely offers similar insights into what some think about AI. A better example might be how Bob Dylan’s fans reacted when he switched from acoustic to electric guitar. What I had falsely anticipated was that the author would examine how digital storage and revision changed writing and the teaching of writing. 

I imagined I would encounter an analysis of changes in personal revision, educator feedback and learner revision, peer revision, and possibly even AI as a sounding board for a writer’s efforts. These are the topics in what I see as the evolution of writing and writing education. I decided to generate a post that would offer my own thoughts about the role of word processing in the writing process. The podcast and the book on word processing are still worth your time. 

Will digital tools change our writing?

I assume you complete many of the writing tasks you take on using a word processing application. Do you do this because you assume this approach makes you more efficient or do you assume this approach makes you a better writer? Maybe you have never even thought about these questions. However, when functioning as a teacher and asking your students to engage in activities in a particular way, it may be helpful to consider why the approach you expect students to use will be productive. Often, to realize the full potential of an activity, the details matter and some insight into why an approach is supposed to be productive may be helpful in understanding  which details to track and emphasize. The following comments summarize some ideas about the value of word processing and of learning to write using word processing applications.

In learning, as in other areas of life, you seldom get something for nothing. Still, a logical case has been proposed for how simply working with word processing for an extended period may improve writing skills and performance. Perkins (1985) calls this the “opportunities get taken” hypothesis. The proposal works like this. Writing by hand on paper has a number of built-in limitations. Generating text this way is slow, and modifying what has been written comes at a substantial price. To produce a second or third draft requires the writer to spend a good deal of time reproducing text that was fine the first time, just to change a few things that might sound better if modified. Word processing, on the other hand, allows writers to revise at minimal cost. They can pursue an idea to see where it takes them and worry about fixing syntax and spelling later. Reworking documents from the level of fixing misspelled words to reordering the arguments in the entire presentation can be accomplished without crumpling up what has just been painstakingly written and starting over.

With word processing, writers can take risks and push their skills without worrying that they may be wasting their time. The capacity to save and load text from some form of storage makes it possible to revise earlier drafts with minimal effort. Writers can set aside what they have written to gain new perspectives, show friends a draft and ask for advice, or discuss an idea with the teacher after class, and use these experiences to improve what they wrote yesterday or last week. What we have described here are opportunities—opportunities to produce a better paper for tomorrow’s class and, over time, opportunities to learn to communicate more effectively. 

Do writers take the opportunities provided by word processing programs and produce better products? The research evaluating the benefits of word processing (MacArthur, 2006; Wollscheid, Sjaastad, & Tømte, 2016) is not easy to interpret. Much seems to depend on the experience of the writer as a writer and familiarity with word processing, and on what is meant by a “better” product. If the questions refer to younger students, it also seems to depend on the instructional strategies to which the students have been exposed. It does appear that access to word processing is more beneficial for older learners and some even interpret this difference as having a neurological basis (Wollscheid, Sjaastad, & Tømte, 2016). General summaries of the research literature (e.g., MacArthur, 2006) seem to indicate that students make more revisions, write longer documents, and produce documents containing fewer errors when word processing. However, the spelling, syntactical, and grammatical errors that students tend to address and the revision activities necessary to correct them are considered less important by many interested in effective writing than changes improving document content or document organization. The natural tendency of most writers appears to be to address surface-level features. 

Writers appear to bring their writing goals and habits to writing with the support of technology. Beginning writers and perhaps writers at many stages of maturity may not have the orientation or capabilities to use the full potential of word processing, and their classroom instruction may also emphasize the correction of more obvious surface errors. Thus, there are typically improvements in the products generated when working with word processing tools, but the areas in which younger writers seem to improve are not necessarily the most important ones

Many of the potential educational advantages of word processing appear only as students acquire considerable experience writing with the aid of technology and some question whether using a keyboard is better than a pencil for young writers (Wollscheid, Sjaastad, & Tømte, 2016). Perkins’s (1985) argument that writing with word processing programs will improve writing skills because word processing allows students to experiment with their writing makes sense only in situations in which students have written a great deal and experimented with expressing themselves in different ways. The fact that most research evaluating the benefits of word processing has examined performance over a short period of time, with students having limited word processing experience, thus represents a poor test of the potential of word processing (Owston, Murphy, & Wideman, 1992). Research based on a three-year study following elementary students as they learned to write with and without access to word processing opportunities has demonstrated a significant advantage for students with ready access to technology (Owston & Wideman, 1997). A recent study (Yamaç, et al., 2020) examining the benefits of consistent writing on laptops found a similar advantage in contrast to paper and pencil writing tasks for early elementary learners. These researchers point to social media activities such as blogs and multimedia writing with tablets as expanding the writing opportunities available in classrooms. 

The National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) demonstrates that in the U.S. greater experience writing with technology is predictive of schools with more proficient writers (Tate, Warschauer & Abedi, 2016). Studies such as this are still controversial as it is difficult to parse out other variables such as the income levels of the majority of students in different schools that may influence both access to technology and writing proficiency. Overall, the role of word processing in developing writing skills depends on the goals of the teacher and individual students, the social context provided for writing, and the amount of writing that students do with the assistance of word processing. 

Summary

Many of the posts I write concern the cognitive processes involved in learning, thinking, and academic behavior. Often, I focus on how these processes are impacted for good or bad by involving technology. We seem to be past the point at which educators question writing on a computer, but the distinction I raised between opportunities get taken and desirable difficulty have yet to be resolved with writing. This is clearly the case when educators debate the role AI should play. My suggestions related to the opportunities get taken hypothesis should also be approached would even be that we examine whether the opportunities (often called affordances) of revision are actually employed. Do students get useful feedback from which they might learn to improve what they have written? Despite the likely benefit of revision, do students quantitatively do much revision? Perhaps like other ideals (tutoring, personalizing learning) that are impractical for one reason or another (e.g., cost, teacher time), AI might find a productive role in guiding revision experiences. 

References:

MacArthur, C.A. (2006). The effects of new technologies on writing and writing processes. In C.A. MacArthur, S. Graham, & j. Fitzgerald (Eds.) Handbook of Writing Research, pps. 248-262. New York: Guilford.

Owston, R., Murphy, S., & Wideman, H. (1992). The effects of word processing on students’ writing quality and revision strategies. Research in the Teaching of English, 26 (3), 249–276.

Owston, R., & Wideman, H. (1997). Word processors and children’s writing in a high-computer-access setting. Journal of Research on Computing in Education, 30 (2), 202–220.

Perkins, D. (1985). The fingertip effect: How information-processing technology shapes thinking. Educational Researcher, 14, 11–17.

Tate, T. P., Warschauer, M., & Abedi, J. (2016). The effects of prior computer use on computer-based writing: the 2011 NAEP writing assessment. Computers & Education, 101, 115-131.

Wollscheid, S., Sjaastad, J., & Tømte, C. (2016). The impact of digital devices vs. Pen (cil) and paper on primary school students’ writing skills–A research review. Computers & Education, 95, 19-35.

Yamaç, A., Öztürk, E., & Mutlu, N. (2020). Effect of digital writing instruction with tablets on primary school students’ writing performance and writing knowledge. Computers & Education, 157, 1-19.

Loading