Future of the participatory Internet.

I would be cool if Clay Shirky (Here comes everybody) and Tim Wu (Master Switch) debated the future of the Internet. I read them to have nearly opposite positions. More and more I am siding with Wu – big corporations are taking over and we seem to be moving toward a provider/consumer model. At best, personal production will be moderated through a big company. Wu seems to suggest that this is the natural way of things and I suppose that unless the government steps in to speak for “everybody” this is the way it works.